Selecting the Best Potting Soil and Potting Mix

Home » Blog » Selecting the Best Potting Soil and Potting Mix

Robert Pavlis

While creating some videos about potting soil (links below) I reviewed a lot of commercial products, looking at both ingredients and marketing claims. What a mess out there! It’s no wonder gardeners are confused when they go out an buy a potting mix. I created this post to try and bring some clarity to the situation.

I will go through a process of selecting a good product while pointing out the important issues and showing you what marketing gibberish you can ignore. This discussion applies to potting soil for houseplants, outdoor containers and starting seeds.

Selecting the Best Potting Soil and Potting Mix, credit: Pistils Nursery
Selecting the Best Potting Soil and Potting Mix, credit: Pistils Nursery

Potting Soil vs Potting Mix vs Potting Compost

What is the difference? I covered that in detail in this video. It depends on where you live, but in short, in the UK potting compost is soil based with added peat or decomposed wood. Australia uses the term potting mix and it’s wood based with no soil. In North America we are totally confused and use both mix and soil, interchangeably. Normally they are peat-based with no soil.

In this post, I will use both potting mix and potting soil interchangeably to get more google hits 🙂 My focus here is on soilless material.

Plant Science for Gardeners by Robert Pavlis

YouTube video

What Does Potting Mix Do For Plants?

This will surprise many of you. It allows plants to grow in what amounts to a hydroponic system which provides support and air. That’s it. We add water and fertilizer. The media is inert and even when it decomposes it adds virtually no nutrients.

Once you understand this, selecting a good potting mix becomes easier.

Selecting a Base Potting Soil

The first criteria is to select your base product and there are three common options; peat, decomposed wood and coir.

Any of the tree options work. If you have access to peat, I would use it since that is the historical standard in horticulture and we know it works well.

Peat Moss

Peat and peat moss are almost the same thing. It has been and still is the gold standard in North America. It was the standard in the UK as well but they are moving away from it and using decomposed wood because of environmental concerns.

Use of peat in horticulture is not nearly as big a problem as the internet would lead you to believe. You can read more about that here, Peat and Peat Moss – the True Environmental Story

Peat slowly decomposes but adds almost no nutrients.

Decomposed Wood

This can be made with a variety of wood products including bark, and is partially decomposed wood. It provides good drainage, lots of air and holds water. It provides few nutrients, in part because of the high C/N ratio.

Garden Fundamentals Facebook Group

Coir

Coir is ground up coconut husk and is playing a bigger role in replacing peat because people are under the incorrect belief that it is a more eco-friendly alternative.  If you look at the whole life cycle of the product you find that production causes significant harm to fresh water in India and Sri Lanka. See, Is Coir an Eco-friendly Substitute for Peat Moss?

It functions very much like peat.

Additives to the Base Potting Mix

Commercial products add lots of additives to the base material. Some of these are beneficial to plants. Others add value but are not needed and some add no value at all. Additives are used mostly to differentiate one product from another. Ignore the claims and understand their real value.

It is common sense to think that plants need lots of different things in their media, but it’s not true. Many orchid mixes include several additives and none are needed. I grew orchids in plain bark for 20 years and then switched to plain coconut husk for the next 25 years. I’ve grown hundreds of species and won regular show awards. Remember epiphytic orchids grow on plain bark in nature.

Orchid growing naturally
Orchid growing naturally, credit:  aboutorchids.com

Charcoal

Charcoal absorbs nutrients which is a good reason not to use it. It is not needed.

Earth Worm Castings

There is a strong unfounded belief that worm poop has special powers. It is just a form of organic fertilizer.

Organic fertilizer does add nutrients, but they also cause a problem in pots. You never know how much nutrient they add. If they decompose faster they add more. If they decompose slower they add less. So you never know if you are under or over feeding your plants.

The “organic” part adds nothing to the plants. The base of your potting mix is already organic matter – adding more does not change things.

Fertilizers

Many products now add fertilizer and that feeds your plants for a couple of months which sounds great, but it is a problem. Is it overfeeding or underfeeding your plants? Does it include calcium and magnesium? If you use soft water you probably need added calcium and magnesium. If you use hard water you don’t want any added.

The manufacturer of the media does not know what kind of water you will use, but you do. So it is much better for you to add the fertilizer you need.

Ignore any added fertilizer and supply your own.

Limestone

Limestone is added to compensate for the acidity of peat moss. Decomposed wood and coir are less acidic and don’t need it.

I tested the pH of peat moss using my tap water which is quite alkaline and the pH of peat rose after a couple of days. If you have similar water you don’t really want limestone in your mix.

The limestone is also not good if you are growing acid loving plants. It is better to add some yourself if you need it.

Meals: Alfalfa, Kelp and Feather

These are all slow release organic fertilizers and as discussed above for worm castings, they don’t really add much value to a mix.

Microbes and Mycorrhizal Fungi

These are becoming hot garden products and they are now added to more potting mixes. Microbes play an important role in real soil, but potted plants are not growing in real soil. Microbes are not need in our pots and it isn’t even clear that they add any benefit. You can grow almost any plant hydroponically without microbes, even orchids.

If you fertilize, the plants do not need microbes and if you add a good level of phosphate then plants won’t even allow mycorrhizal fungi to connect to them.

These additives add no value, but they don’t do any harm either, except to your pocketbook.

Perlite

Finally an additive that is worth adding. Perlite increases drainage and air in the media. It will make your base media drier and provide more air at the roots. It also compensates a bit for overwatering – which is a very common problem.

If a commercial potting soil contains perlite it is usually only a small amount. You might want to add some more.

YouTube video

Sand

The addition of sand increases drainage. It does the same as perlite, except that it is heavier and therefore makes the mix heavier. That can be an advantage for small tippy pots but it’s not so great for large planters that need to be moved around.

Rather than buying a product that contains sand, add it yourself if it is needed.

Soil (loam)

Soil seems to only be added to a mix in the UK, where it is a major component. I have no idea why the UK and US are so different in this regard – we grow the same plants.

Vermiculite

Vermiculite also makes the media drain better, but unlike perlite it holds more water resulting in a wetter mix. Perlite seems more popular in commercial mixes than vermiculite and since most gardeners have a tendency to overwater, I’d stick with perlite.

What Are the Best Additives?

Which additives do you want in a purchased product? Some perlite or sand is an advantage. The rest add little or no value so add them yourself if and when they are needed.

Marketing Potting Soil

Marketing hype also confuses the purchasing process with a number of words or claims that really don’t mean much and add no value to the product. Ignore all of the following.

Black Soil

I always get a chuckle about this one. Gardeners associate black with good soil. So if you are selling “potting soil”, why not call it “Black Potting Soil”?

The word black tells you nothing about the quality of the product. Ignore it on bags of potting soil and on bags of real soil where the term is used even more.

Organic Soil

The word organic has been abused so much that it doesn’t mean much any more. There is no such thing as “organically certified potting mix” but products are labeled as organic.

There are OMRI certified products, but that designation means that the material can be used in organic farming. I am not sure how that helps a gardener growing houseplants or even raising seedlings for a vegetable garden.

The word organic on a bag adds no value.

Natural Soil

The main ingredients are either peat, coir or wood – all of these are natural. That means all potting soil is natural even if the bag is not labeled as such.

Sterile Soil

There is no such thing as sterile soil. It is possible that the mixture was sterilized or that one or more ingredients are sterilized, but packaging facilities for potting mix are not sterile environments. And even it the manufacturer did produce a sterile product, as soon as you place a plant in it, it is no longer sterile.

Most of the ingredients in potting soil are fairly pest free and sterility is not really an issue. Any pests in potting media either get in there during the bulk storage period, during packaging or after you open the bag.

Big Plants and More Blooms

Such labels are quite comical. Remember that the potting media is a hydroponic system that provides very little to the plant. Growth and flowering are mostly determined by temperature, humidity, fertilizer levels, water and light. You can grow big plants with lots of blooms in just about any media provided the other parameters are correct and there is enough air for roots to grow.

Specialty Blends

There are special blends for plant categories like succulents, African violets, vegetables, and even seed starting mixes. None of these are needed.

There are also some gimmicky blends like “moisture control media”. You don’t need that either. You control moisture by watering correctly.

Some plants do require a drier or wetter environment and I suggest using the base product and amending it when needed with sand, perlite or vermiculite.

What is the Best Potting Mix?

Select the base material. Then look for a product that uses this base and does not have too many additives.

Name brands tend to be better than no-name brands. Really cheap brands are not worth buying, but you also don’t need the most expensive ones. You pay high prices for special additives that are not needed, or for over priced branding.

Once you find a brand that works for you, stick with it. Over time you will get to know it and understand how to properly water it. This is much better than constantly switching brands to save a dollar or two.

Figure out how much you can use over a couple of years and buy in bulk. It will save you money and media does not get old, provided it is kept dry.

What do I use? I have been using ProMix for many years. It is peat-based and has a bit of perlite in it. It now comes with mycorrhizal fungi which add no value. ProMix is also used a lot in the horticulture industry.

For succulents, I add some sand. For plants that like to be on the dry side, I add some perlite. For outdoor containers I add garden soil which translates into much less watering – see video below. But for all seedlings and 95% of houseplants I use straight ProMix.

Will other mixes work just as well as ProMix? I am sure they will. Buy a good product that is available locally and stick with it.

YouTube video

If you like this post, please share .......

Robert Pavlis

I have been gardening my whole life and have a science background. Besides writing and speaking about gardening, I own and operate a 6 acre private garden called Aspen Grove Gardens which now has over 3,000 perennials, grasses, shrubs and trees. Yes--I am a plantaholic!

25 thoughts on “Selecting the Best Potting Soil and Potting Mix”

  1. I come to your page when I need assurance of how I feel about products – I am in Australia and recently started work at a retail nursery, they sell this range of potting mixes – one product calls itself a planting mix but may be used in pots as a potting mix or in the ground as a planting mix – is this possible – to be used in the ground or in pots? And I know you are going to say – why would you need to put it in the ground 🙂 The same brand also has Garden Soil and Garden Compost but they both have added coir, fertiliser/trace elements and a wetting agent. The nursery staff regular recommend adding these products when back filling a planting hole – I am not comfortable with that, and I was only going to go so far as saying the compost “might” be ok until I found out about the additives. I cannot imagine those extras in a planting hole. Why are all these things added? And why is there not more education for the public? I feel it is my role to advice gardeners but feel quite compromised with these products.

    Reply
    • 1) Manufacturers sell more product if gardeners stay uninformed – they have no reason to inform gardeners.
      2) I don’t see a problem with the additives. They may not add any benefit, but they won’t hurt either. I am no expert on Australis, but you do have areas where the soil is very hydrophobic and the wetting agent may be helpful. In fact some places in Australia routinely add a setting agent to soil. Coir is just a form of undecomposed organic matter. Probably not a great thing to add to soil from an environmental perspective, but it won’t harm it either. Since Australia is closer to India and Shri Lanka where coir is made, it may be more sustainable to use it than peat moss from Canada.
      3) Planting mix – potting mix – names don’t matter much. The ingredients are more important. Assuming these contain organic matter, adding them to soil helps retain nutrients in sandy soil, and holds more moisture.

      https://www.gardenmyths.com/coir-ecofriendly-substitute-peat-moss/

      Reply
  2. I live in Florida and my soil is mostly sand except for my ornamental plant beds that I have amended with shredded bark mulch, cow manure and fall leaves. Would you still recommend that I use the normal soil that hasn’t been amended or my amended soil in containers. There really isn’t much clay at all in my native soil.

    Reply
  3. I have used Premier Pro-Mix BX for over 20 years for my house plants and seed starting.It comes in a compressed bale and you have loosen it up and wet it using a light spray from a watering nozzle and mix to get the medium evenly wet.This is much cheaper than buying the loose bags of the same product if you use quite a lot of it.Once I have got it wet I store it in 20 litre buckets with lids or in heavy black plastic sand bags closed with twist ties made copper wire.Even if you store it outside in winter you can bring one two bags inside and they thaw out in a couple of days.I

    Reply
  4. I can’t tell you how grateful I am to have found your blog & books. Recently read Soil Science — it was fantastic!

    Question for you: If planting seedlings in soilless mix, will they eventually need some fertilizer? Sounds like they’ll get calcium/magnesium from hard water. What about other nutrients? You mention fertilizer briefly above. After over fertilizing in the garden last summer, I’m a bit gun shy 🙂 and seedlings seem like a totally different ball game!

    Reply
  5. Recently started reading your informative posts. Could you kindly educate me on the effectiveness of foliar spray {organic and chemicals some experts say are useless? Sri Lanka has a tropical climate.Thanks

    Reply
    • foliar sprays work for some things and don’t work for others. They are not a good idea for gardeners because gardeners don’t understand when and how to use them.

      Reply
  6. Hello. I’ve seen some people recommend leaf mould instead of coir/peat as a sustainable source for the base material, do you have any thoughts on it? It does take a long time to produce (up to a couple of years), but its also easily sourced for many from just neightborhood leaves in the autumn left to compost over winter.

    Reply
  7. Purchased the most expensive brand of Australian potting mix with the 5 tick standard. Was most disappointed to find MANY lumps of wood in it, which makes it difficult to push long stem cuttings in 🙁

    Reply
  8. Hi Robert, have you given any consideration to the cocoons of jumping worms in bagged ‘soils’? As you are aware, the worms have been identified in the Hamilton/Dundas area and have turned up in bagged soils. Thoughts on how to deal with this? Thank you.

    Reply
    • I don’t expect them to show up in potting soil.

      In bagged soil – yes. They are in the area, and there is not much we can do to slow them down or stop them. Unless we find a biological agent that can control them, we won’t control them.

      Reply
      • I am pretty sure that if you heat up the potting mix in a microwave (4kg take about 11 minutes in an 800W) the heat will also kill the worms.

        Reply
  9. Sterilized leads me to believe that it is heat-treated and thus kills weed seeds. Maybe not an issue with potting mix but could be for compost. Not sure if I am right on that assumption.

    Reply
  10. I prefer vermiculite to perlite. Perlite tends to float to the top of the container and does tend to be friable. I agree that vermiculite tends to retain more moisture but that is not a problem as long as you watch your watering frequency.

    Reply
  11. Hi Robert,

    Just for your information, there exist different John Innes Composts

    https://www.rhs.org.uk/soil-composts-mulches/john-innes-compost

    No3 is the most popular I believe. Maybe that lifts your confusion.

    I started to use the baggy method for germination and use a mix of peat and (real) compost for growing on. For feed I use liquid urea fertilizer (150ppm N). I get good results with this.

    I offen had problems with damping off and I found that microwaving really helps to reduce damping-off. And it is really convenient too. This paper confirms that this no hokus:
    https://www.apsnet.org/publications/phytopathology/backissues/Documents/1984Abstracts/Phyto74_121.htm

    Thanks for your interesting post. I learn a lot.

    Reply
    • John Innes 1, 2 and 3 are all soil based.

      Microwaves won’t kill the microorganisms – it doesn’t even kill fruit flies, but the heated water and steam will kill them.

      Reply
  12. I’ve found perlite will break down after about 2 years into a fine powder that substantially reduces drainage. Have you found this to be a problem?

    Reply
  13. So why do the extension offices and master gardener classes make such a big point of saying potted plants do better in potting soil than in garden soil/compost? old wives tales that just get passed along? maybe comparing 100% soil with no compost? I did a casual search for studies but didn’t find any. I have one large pot I used 100% horse manure compost in last year (I compost the manure from my ponies-90% Bermuda hay)- plants grew fine but I had to frequently water, I’ll try adding some garden soil this spring and see what happens. FYI SE Arizona, 15% humidity and 100+ all summer.

    Reply
    • Garden soil contains less air than potting soil. Plants in pots have limited space and you need a good set of roots to do well.
      This post is not talking about garden soil, except the video about using soils in containers. In that case the garden soil has a fair amount of clay, which is why it holds more water.

      Potting soil would work better in my container, but I would need to water more often. I accept slower growth and gain less watering.

      Reply

Please leave a comment either here or in our Facebook Group: Garden Fundamentals